Fireplace Makeovers

How to Update a Brass Fireplace Without Replacing It

How to update a brass fireplace without replacing it: check if it's solid brass, prep and paint with high-heat paint, and choose doors and trim that fit.

On this page
  1. Find out what the brass is
  2. Choose paint, blackening or removal
  3. Prep the trim
  4. Paint and cure
  5. Doors and glass
  6. Louvers, vents and trim you should leave alone
  7. Safety
  8. Common mistakes

Brass trim from the 1980s and 1990s is common on older fireplaces, and it often dates a room more than anything else. You can update it without replacing the whole unit. The keys are knowing what the brass is, prepping it properly and using paint rated for heat.

Find out what the brass is

Start with a magnet. If the trim sticks, it’s plated steel. If it doesn’t stick, it’s solid brass or aluminum. The result changes the finish you should use.

Typical brass on older units includes glass door frames, trim bars, prefab hoods and louver trim. Much of it is lacquered brass-plated steel.

Choose paint, blackening or removal

  • High-heat paint: Spray paint rated around 1,200°F is the most common route. Matte or satin black is the usual choice for a modern look.
  • Blackening solution: Solid brass can be darkened with a brass-blackening solution instead of paint.
  • Removal: Some brass trim bars unscrew, and taking them off can simplify the look without any finishing.
  • Wax-based metallics: Products such as Rub ’n Buff aren’t heat-rated. Use them only on trim well away from heat.

Prep the trim

Remove the doors if you can, and work only on cold doors. Degrease the metal. Strip the lacquer with lacquer thinner or acetone, and wear the right protection while you do it. Scuff the surface with 220 to 320 grit or a gray abrasive pad, then wipe it down with solvent again.

Mask the glass carefully, or remove the glass panels before you paint.

Paint and cure

Apply two or three light coats within the recoat window printed on the can. Heavy coats run, and they can cure unevenly.

Cure the paint with heat as the can directs. Schedules vary by brand. Expect odor and some smoke on the first few fires, so ventilate the room well during the first burns.

Doors and glass

Glass doors have limits. Tempered glass has a lower temperature limit than ceramic glass, and many manufacturers say tempered doors should stay open during hot fires. Check the maker’s rating before you use the doors with a fire.

If you replace the doors, measure the opening at the top and bottom for width, and measure the height on both sides. For a prefab fireplace, use only doors listed for that specific model. A door that fits the opening may still not be approved for the unit.

Louvers, vents and trim you should leave alone

Don’t paint louvers closed, and don’t remove them to make the look simpler. Louvers and vents are there for airflow. Prefab units can overheat or behave unsafely when airflow is blocked, so keep them open and clear.

Safety

  • Turn off the gas and the pilot before you spray near a gas fireplace. Aerosols can ignite.
  • Work on cold doors and trim only.
  • Wear a respirator when you spray paint, and ventilate the room.

Common mistakes

  • Using regular spray paint on door frames, which get hot and can fail
  • Painting over lacquered brass without stripping and scuffing first
  • Buying glass doors that aren’t listed for the prefab unit
  • Painting louvers closed to hide them

For a broader look at modern fireplace finishes, including black doors and hardware, see how to make your fireplace look more modern. For more ideas across the whole fireplace, see fireplace makeover ideas.

The complete guide to fireplace makeovers

Fireplace Makeover Ideas: Modern Designs on Any Budget
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →