To make a fireplace look more modern, simplify the lines. Smooth or simplify the surround, swap a heavy mantel for a slim shelf or none at all, use large-format tile and switch brass for black. Keep the clearance rules in mind for any wood or floating shelf you add.
Simplify the surround
Paint is the quickest change. A solid matte white, charcoal or black heat-resistant paint can make an old brick face look current. If you want texture, a soft limewash works too, but limewash only bonds to clean, unpainted brick. For more on brick finishes, see brick fireplace makeover ideas.
A smooth finish gives a seamless look. Lime plaster, microcement or a mortar skim coat can cover old brick, but the brick must be clean, with a bonding primer or base coat first. Sooty or painted brick doesn’t take a skim coat well without prep.
Large-format tile reduces grout lines and gives a cleaner, more architectural look. Porcelain, marble, limestone or concrete-look slabs, at 24 by 48 inches or larger, work well. Keep grout joints around 1/16 to 1/8 inch.
Extend the surround floor to ceiling for a vertical focal point. This often looks more modern than a surround that stops at a traditional mantel.
Swap or remove the mantel
A thick floating wood shelf in oak or walnut, or a flush steel beam, is a common swap for an ornate mantel.
Floating mantels still follow the masonry clearance rules. Keep combustible shelves at least 6 inches from a masonry opening, and no more than 1/8 inch of projection for each inch of distance within 12 inches. That means a mantel deeper than 1.5 inches needs to sit at least 12 inches above a masonry opening. Prefab units follow their manual.
Some people take the surround straight to the ceiling with no mantel at all. If you remove a raised hearth, keep the hearth extension the code requires.
Update the firebox, doors and hardware
Paint the firebox and any metal trim with a matte black high-heat paint rated around 1,200°F. Ordinary black paint won’t hold up inside the firebox.
Swap brass doors for black, minimal-frame glass doors. Prefab units need doors listed for that specific model. Don’t remove doors unless the manual allows it.
Black steel tools and screens look more current than ornate brass. Swap them in for a simple change that reads as modern.
Choose a linear look
A wide, low linear unit can make the fireplace look modern. A gas insert with a low glass front or a modern wood insert can do this. An electric unit with a minimalist glass front is another option. Each has to be listed for the firebox it goes in.
Gas isn’t required for a modern look. A wood-burning fireplace can look current with the right surround, mantel and hardware.
Style it simply
Use one large piece of art or a mirror, plus two or three objects. Keep the hearth uncluttered, and use black steel for any firewood holder. Built-ins on each side with slab doors and integrated lighting can also suit a modern wall. For lighting, see fireplace lighting ideas.
Myths to drop
- A modern look requires switching to gas. It doesn’t.
- Any black paint works on the firebox. Use high-heat paint.
- Plaster or tile bonds to sooty or painted brick. Clean and prime first.
- Floating mantels are exempt from clearances. They aren’t.
Safety while you work
Wear an N95 or better respirator when you demolish, grind or cut brick and tile. Brick dust contains silica. Turn off the gas before you work near a gas fireplace.
For brass trim, see how to update a brass fireplace without replacing it. For more ideas across the whole fireplace, see fireplace makeover ideas.