Fireplace Makeovers

Stone Fireplace Surrounds: Modern Designs and DIY Stone Veneer

Modern stone fireplace surround ideas and DIY stone veneer steps: weight and framing checks, mortar, dry-stack vs grout, and realistic installed costs.

On this page
  1. Modern stone looks
  2. Manufactured stone vs. natural thin stone
  3. Cost: materials, freight and installation
  4. Check the wall before you start
  5. Plan the layout and the mantel
  6. Install the veneer, step by step
  7. Grout, caulk and cure
  8. Cutting, temperature and safety
  9. Clearances for wood trim and mantels
  10. When to bring in a pro

A stone surround is one of the most dramatic fireplace updates, and one of the most physical. Stone veneer is heavy, dusty and slow to install. Before you order anything, decide between a dry-stacked modern look and a grouted one, and check whether your wall can take the work.

Modern stone looks

Stone suits modern rooms when it’s kept simple. Common choices include long linear ledgestone, honed limestone and stone slabs. Run the stone floor to ceiling for a vertical focal point, and pair it with a floating steel or wood mantel.

Dry-stacking, with tight joints and no grout, is the usual modern look. Keep in mind that veneer thickness varies from piece to piece, so a dry stack shows every uneven edge. Sort the stones before you start so you can see the range of sizes and thicknesses.

Manufactured stone vs. natural thin stone

Manufactured stone veneer is cast concrete, usually about 1 to 2.5 inches thick, and typically under 15 pounds per square foot. It’s the lighter choice and the one most DIY installs use.

Natural thin stone is about 3/4 to 1.5 inches thick and is also typically under 15 pounds per square foot. Full-bed stone is heavier and may need footing or ledge support, so check with a structural pro before you choose it for a fireplace.

Cost: materials, freight and installation

Manufactured stone often runs about $6 to $12 per square foot for material, and installed costs commonly fall between $20 and $50 per square foot. Prices vary a lot by region and product.

Freight can be a large share of the total. One DIY blogger’s 60-square-foot project came to about $3,200 all-in, and shipping alone was roughly $1,000 because the stone is heavy. Ask for the delivered price before you commit, and plan for how the pallets will reach the wall.

Check the wall before you start

The substrate decides how the stone attaches:

  • Clean, unpainted, unsealed brick or concrete can take veneer directly if water soaks in quickly. Test this before you buy.
  • Painted or sealed brick, or drywall: Fasten galvanized metal lath (at least 2.5 pounds per square yard) into the studs or masonry, then apply a scratch coat of about 1/2 inch, and let it cure.
  • Cement board: Some brands allow direct application to 1/2-inch cement board without lath. Check the manufacturer’s instructions.

Regular drywall isn’t a good base for stone. Strip the drywall back to the studs, and look for wires and plumbing before you pull it off. Then add blocking for the TV and mantel while the wall is open, so you have something solid to fasten to later.

Plan the layout and the mantel

Lay the stones out on the floor or a tarp first. Mix sizes and colors, and avoid long continuous vertical or horizontal seams. Plan the corners first, since they set the lines for the rest of the wall, and work in sections of five to ten stones.

If you’re adding a mantel, install it before the stone. Setting the mantel after the stone leaves little room for error: too small leaves wide grout lines, and too large means cutting the stone to fit.

Install the veneer, step by step

  1. Start at the bottom. Shim the first course so it’s level and sits slightly off the floor. Work upward from the corners, and set the corner pieces before the field stones.
  2. Mix the mortar. Use Type S or N mortar, or the veneer manufacturer’s mortar, following the bag. Aim for a consistency close to creamy peanut butter. Mix only as much as you can use before it starts to stiffen.
  3. Back-butter each stone. Spread about 1/2 inch of mortar on the back, comb it with a notched trowel, press the stone into place and wiggle it slightly. Mortar should squeeze out at the edges. In dry weather, dampen the stone and the wall first.
  4. Cut as needed. Use a wet tile saw or an angle grinder with a diamond blade. Chip the cut edges with a hammer or chisel to make them look natural. Super glue can hold a broken piece together while you set it.
  5. Leave joint space. Keep a small gap between stones for grout. Cardboard spacers help hold the layout while the mortar sets.

Grout, caulk and cure

Let the mortar cure before you grout. Cure time depends on the product, often 12 to 48 hours. Pipe the grout with a grout bag into joints 1/2 inch or narrower, and keep the joints flush or slightly recessed.

Tool the joints once the grout has stiffened. A thumbprint should leave only a faint mark. Timing varies with temperature and humidity, so test a few joints first. Caulk the gap where the stone meets the ceiling or trim, in a color that matches the grout.

Install the veneer above 40°F, and dampen the stone in very dry conditions. Let the mortar cure fully before you run a hot fire. Full cure can take several days, depending on the product.

Cutting, temperature and safety

Wear gloves, since cement burns, along with eye protection and an N95 or better respirator when cutting. Wet cutting keeps dust down, so use water with the saw where you can.

Clearances for wood trim and mantels

Stone doesn’t change the clearance rules for wood. A wood mantel or trim still needs its clearances from the opening. Polyurethane “faux stone” panels are combustible plastic, so they aren’t the same as stone veneer. Check the product before using one near a fire.

When to bring in a pro

A stone surround is a multi-day job, not a weekend project. Expect sore hands, a lot of dust and a few mistakes along the way. If the wall needs structural work, or if the stone is heavy natural stone, a pro with fireplace or masonry experience is worth the cost.

For wood surrounds and wall panels as a lighter alternative, see DIY fireplace surround plans. For brick as a base or as an alternative, see brick fireplace makeover ideas. For the full range of options, see fireplace makeover ideas.

The complete guide to fireplace makeovers

Fireplace Makeover Ideas: Modern Designs on Any Budget
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →