Fireplace Makeovers

Fireplace Makeover Ideas: Modern Designs on Any Budget

Fireplace makeover ideas on any budget: cosmetic updates, modern designs, electric and gas options, plus clearance and safety basics before you start.

On this page
  1. Start with a cosmetic update
  2. Modern looks that work
  3. Surrounds and wall panels
  4. Corner, shiplap and brass fireplaces
  5. Lighting, decor and styling
  6. Layout, seating and the TV
  7. Electric, ethanol and gas options
  8. Know the limits before you start
  9. Typical costs
  10. Where to start

Fireplace makeovers range from a weekend paint job to a full remodel. The fireplace type and your budget set the approach. If the unit works, a cosmetic update is the cheapest way to change how the room looks. If the firebox or flue needs work, a makeover won’t fix it, so check the unit first.

Start with a cosmetic update

The least expensive makeovers change the surface, not the structure.

Modern looks that work

A modern fireplace usually has clean lines, few ornaments and one strong material. Large-format porcelain or stone, a smooth plaster finish and black hardware all help. Taking the surround to the ceiling with no traditional mantel gives a vertical focal point.

For a step-by-step guide to modernizing, see how do I make my fireplace look more modern?.

Surrounds and wall panels

A new surround can change a fireplace more than paint can. Stone veneer is heavy and labor intensive, so plan the substrate and the weight first. For stone options, see stone fireplace surrounds. For wood, MDF and wall-panel choices, see DIY fireplace surround plans.

Wall panels vary. Stone, concrete, metal and porcelain slab can sit near a firebox when installed as listed. Wood slats, MDF and PVC or polyurethane panels can’t, so keep them outside the clearance zone.

Corner, shiplap and brass fireplaces

Corner fireplaces often need an overmantel or a build-out to look finished. For the framing and finishes, see corner fireplace makeover ideas.

Lighting, decor and styling

Sconces, recessed lights and LED accents can make a fireplace wall feel finished at night. Keep lights out of a wood-burning firebox, and keep fixtures out of the heat above the opening. See fireplace lighting ideas.

For what to hang above the mantel, see what to put above a fireplace. For styling a wood-burning hearth and mantel, see how to style a wood-burning fireplace.

Layout, seating and the TV

Furniture placement depends on the fire. Upholstered furniture should sit at least 3 feet from a working fireplace. For sofa direction, see should your couch face the fireplace?. For clearance distances, see furniture in front of a fireplace.

A TV above a fireplace usually sits too high for comfortable viewing. For height and mounting, see how high should a TV hang above a fireplace?.

Electric, ethanol and gas options

Electric fireplaces are the simplest to install. They usually run on a 120-volt plug and produce about 1,500 watts of heat, and they need no venting. Ethanol units also need no vent, but they produce little heat.

Real wood-burning and gas fireplaces are a different job. For what a homeowner can build and what needs a permit, see can you make your own fireplace?. For resale value by type, see what type of fireplace adds the most value?.

Know the limits before you start

  • Clearances: Keep anything that can burn at least 6 inches from a masonry opening. Within 12 inches, trim can project no more than 1/8 inch for each inch of distance. Prefab and gas units follow their manuals.
  • Louvers and vents: Never cover them, and don’t block gas control access panels.
  • Decorative fireplaces: Never burn a fire in a faux or decorative unit that wasn’t built for one.
  • Alarms: Install CO and smoke alarms near any fuel-burning fireplace.
  • Old paint: Painted surfaces in homes built before 1978 may contain lead. Test before you sand.
  • Dust: Wear an N95 or better respirator when cutting or grinding brick, stone or tile.
  • The flue and chimney: A makeover doesn’t fix flue, liner or damper problems. Have the chimney inspected before you change the unit or the surround.

Typical costs

These are approximate, and they vary widely by region.

Work Typical range
Paint or limewash (DIY) About $50 to $300
Mantel shelf About $100 to $1,500
Tile surround About $500 to $3,000
Stone veneer About $1,500 to $6,000
Full remodel About $5,000 to $20,000 or more
Insert, installed (wood) About $3,000 to $6,000 or more
Insert, installed (gas) About $3,000 to $7,000 or more
Electric mantel package About $300 to $2,000

Where to start

  1. Identify the fireplace. Is it masonry, prefab, gas or electric? Check the rating plate and the manual.
  2. Check the unit. Have a chimney or heating pro look at the flue and the firebox if it’s been a while.
  3. Choose the look. Decide between a cosmetic update, a modern surround or a full remodel.
  4. Check the clearances for any wood, MDF or combustible panel before you cut.
  5. Follow the detailed guide for the finish you picked, from the links above.

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →