Quick answer
You can replace a wood fireplace with an electric insert or a log set. This avoids a gas line and a new chimney, but an electric unit gives supplemental heat, not whole-house heat. Most fireboxes need an outlet added, which usually means an electrician. The chimney should still be closed off and capped.
Your options
- Electric insert. Sits in the firebox, with trim to cover the gap around the opening.
- Electric log set. Sits on the hearth and plugs into an outlet. It needs no opening work.
- Wall-mount or built-in unit. Placed over a closed-off opening. This suits a room where the firebox isn’t being used.
How much heat it gives
A standard 120-volt plug-in unit draws about 1,500 watts, which is roughly 5,100 BTU per hour. That’s enough supplemental heat for about 400 square feet. Larger hardwired 240-volt units exist, but check the manual for their circuit requirements.
Electric heat is about 100% efficient at the point of use. What it costs to run depends on your local electricity rate. Electric fireplaces don’t heat a whole house.
Electrical needs
- Outlet. Most fireboxes have no outlet. An electrician usually adds a receptacle inside or next to the firebox.
- Circuit. Use a dedicated 15- or 20-amp circuit when you can.
- No extension cords. Don’t run the unit from an extension cord or power strip.
- Flame-only mode. Many units can run the flames without heat, at roughly 10 to 100 watts with LED lighting. The figure depends on the model.
Installing the unit
- Clean the firebox of wood, ash and soot.
- Measure the opening. Record the width, the height, and the depth at the floor and at the top. How to measure your fireplace for an insert walks through each one.
- Plan the power. Place the outlet, or have an electrician hardwire the unit.
- Position the unit. Add a simple support frame if the opening needs one, slide the unit in, and secure it.
- Add trim. The unit’s trim or a surround covers gaps around the opening.
- Test it. Check the flames, the heat setting and the controls.
Care for the chimney
Close the damper. Add a chimney cap, and consider a removable chimney balloon, to stop drafts and keep out rain, debris and animals. An unused flue still collects water and debris, so check it from time to time.
What it costs
These are typical ranges for the parts of the job, and they vary by model and region:
- Electric insert: about $300 to $2,500 or more.
- Electrician: about $150 to $800 or more, for the outlet or hardwiring.
- Trim or surround: varies widely, depending on the finish.
A basic plug-in log set costs much less than a full insert.
Will it raise your electric bill?
It depends on the wattage, how long you run it, and your rate. To estimate the cost of heat:
- Divide the heater’s watts by 1,000 to get kilowatts. A 1,500-watt heater is 1.5 kilowatts.
- Multiply by the hours it runs. Running that heater for 4 hours uses 6 kilowatt-hours.
- Multiply by your electricity rate, which you’ll find on your bill.
Flame-only mode adds very little. Check your bill’s rate, and run the numbers for the settings you actually use.
Downsides
- It gives supplemental heat, not whole-house heat.
- It needs electricity, so it won’t heat your room in a power outage.
- The flames are simulated. There’s no real fire, no crackle of wood and no wood smell.
- Most fireboxes need an electrician to add an outlet.
- If the chimney is left in place, it still needs a cap and moisture protection.
Can you put an electric fire in a chimney breast?
Often, yes. An electric insert or wall unit can sit in an existing fireplace recess, as long as the unit fits the opening, an outlet is in place, and the flue is closed off and capped.
Can you leave it plugged in?
It depends on the model, and the manual is the authority. Plug it into a suitable outlet, not an extension cord or a power strip. If the unit is hardwired, its switch and breaker should be checked by an electrician.
Removing an electric fireplace later
Removing a plug-in unit is usually simple. Hardwired units need an electrician.
- Turn off the power. Switch off the breaker, and unplug the cord.
- Let it cool. Wait for the heating elements and the glass to cool completely.
- Remove the glass or trim. Look for screws, latches or hooks.
- Unscrew the main unit. Mounting screws are usually inside the cavity or around the flange. A mantel or surround may need to come off first.
- Slide it out. Pull the unit forward at an angle, and unplug or disconnect it. Heavy stone or concrete surrounds need a second person, or a dolly and a pry bar.
Removal costs depend on what’s built around the unit and whether it’s hardwired. The bigger expense is usually the finishing work after the unit comes out. For closing the opening properly, see how to remove or permanently close a wood-burning fireplace.
Going back to wood
Before you light a wood fire, remove the outlet and the wiring from the firebox, sweep the chimney, and get a Level 2 chimney inspection. Never burn anything in the firebox while wiring is present. Keep the manual’s clearance from curtains and furniture, which is often about 3 feet.
Common misconceptions
- “Electric fireplaces heat a whole house.” They’re supplemental heaters.
- “Once it’s electric, the chimney needs nothing.” It still needs a cap and moisture protection.
- “You can light a wood fire with the unit removed and the outlet still there.” Remove the wiring and get the chimney inspected first.
- “Electric is always cheaper to run.” It depends on your electricity rate.
For the other side of this choice, see fireplace inserts: types and models, or converting a fireplace to a wood stove if you want the heat of wood back.