Quick answer
Yes, almost always. Virtually all current insert listings require a liner, usually one that runs the full length of the chimney from the insert to the top. An insert is sized for a much smaller flue than most fireplaces have, so the existing chimney has to be lined to draft properly and stay safe.
Why an insert needs its own liner
A masonry fireplace flue is much larger than an insert’s exhaust. When an insert vents into an oversized flue, you get several problems:
- Poor draft. Smoke moves slowly and can spill back into the room.
- Cool flue gases. Gases cool in the large flue and leave more creosote behind.
- Creosote buildup. Without a liner, creosote collects in the smoke chamber, where it’s hard to sweep. It can feed a chimney fire.
A liner gives the insert a flue sized to its exhaust, so smoke moves up and out with a steady draft.
What the code and listings require
The minimum under NFPA 211 is a “positive connection” from the insert to the first flue tile. In practice, a full-length liner is the recommended and common standard, and most insert listings call for one. In Canada, the CSA B365 standard requires a full-length liner for inserts.
Follow the insert’s manual. If the listing calls for a full-length liner, a shorter connection isn’t a substitute, even if it passes a quick look.
Can you use the existing clay liner?
Generally, no. A clay tile liner is sized for an open fireplace, not an insert, so the size mismatch causes the draft and creosote problems described above. Many chimneys have an old clay liner that’s still in place. Have a chimney professional check it, but don’t assume it will do. “My chimney already has a liner, so I’m fine” is a common misconception.
What a liner system includes
A full installation usually includes:
- the liner itself, run from the insert to the top of the chimney
- a top plate and cap at the chimney crown
- a connector from the liner to the insert
- a block-off plate at the damper, which seals the liner around the damper area and keeps heat out of the chimney
- insulation around the liner, if needed
The block-off plate matters for comfort as well as safety. It stops heat from escaping into the chimney and stops cold air from dropping down into the room.
Choosing the material and size
- Material. Use a stainless steel liner listed to UL 1777. For wood, use a higher grade of stainless, such as 316Ti or 316L. Aluminum and 304 stainless are not suitable for wood.
- Diameter. Match the insert’s flue collar, which is commonly 6 inches. Don’t reduce the diameter unless the manual allows it.
- Type. Liners can be flexible or rigid. The choice depends on the chimney’s shape and the installer’s recommendation.
- Insulation. Insulation, either a blanket wrap or a pour-in mix, improves draft and reduces creosote. Some installations need it to meet clearance requirements.
Gas and pellet inserts
Gas inserts usually use a co-linear kit or two 3-inch liners, one for intake and one for exhaust. Pellet inserts typically use a 3- to 4-inch liner. Follow the manufacturer’s specification for the model you’re installing.
Cost and lifespan
Installed cost for a wood insert liner is about $1,000 to $3,000 or more. The price varies with the chimney’s height and whether it’s insulated. Stainless steel liners often last 15 to 20 years or more, if they’re cared for. Many liner warranties are described as lifetime, but they usually depend on conditions, such as annual sweeping and burning only wood. Read the terms before you buy.
Signs your liner needs attention
Have a chimney professional look at the liner if you notice:
- cracks, gaps or missing sections
- fragments of tile or liner material in the firebox
- heavy creosote buildup
- water or condensation in the chimney
- smoke coming back into the room
Safety
Chimney fires in unlined installs can crack masonry and spread to the framing. Sweep the chimney at least once a year, and keep carbon monoxide alarms installed near the appliance.
For more on what an insert needs before it goes in, see how to measure your fireplace for an insert. If the insert is already installed and not heating well, why your fireplace insert isn’t heating the room covers the draft and liner checks.