Inserts and Conversions

Who makes the best wood-burning fireplace?

There's no single best brand. Learn how to judge wood-burning fireplaces, inserts and zero-clearance units, and which makers are commonly named.

On this page
  1. Quick answer
  2. Start with the type you need
  3. How to judge a brand
  4. Brands often named, by category
  5. Warranties
  6. Installation matters as much as the brand
  7. Local rules
  8. Checklist before you buy

Quick answer

There’s no single best brand. The right maker depends on the type of unit you need, whether you want mainly heat or mainly ambiance, and whether you can get good dealer support and parts. Judge each unit on its EPA certification, tested efficiency, real heat output, warranty and local service, not on its highest rated BTU.

Start with the type you need

Brands specialize, so start by deciding which type of unit you’re buying:

  • Zero-clearance (prefab) fireplace. A factory-built metal firebox framed into a new or remodeled wall. It uses the maker’s listed chimney system.
  • Insert. A closed unit that slides into an existing fireplace, usually masonry, and vents through a liner. For more on the difference, see fireplace insert vs zero clearance fireplace.
  • Traditional open-style zero-clearance unit. These give more ambiance than heat.
  • Masonry alternatives. Site-built kits and masonry heaters. These are heavy, expensive, and need a specialist.

How to judge a brand

Compare each unit on the same points:

  • EPA certification and emissions. Confirm the specific model is certified, not just the brand.
  • Tested efficiency. Look for the tested figure for your model.
  • Real heat output. Rated maximums are often optimistic. Compare the output and the space the manufacturer says it heats, and check whether the figure is realistic for your home.
  • Warranty and parts. Check what’s covered and for how long, and whether parts are easy to get.
  • Local dealer and installer. A nearby dealer who can install and service the unit is worth a lot.

Brands often named, by category

These brands come up often in US discussions. Product lines change, so check current models and specifications before you buy.

  • High-efficiency zero-clearance wood fireplaces: Quadra-Fire, Kozy Heat, RSF, Regency, Lopi (Travis Industries), Napoleon, Osburn and Valcourt.
  • Wood inserts: Regency, Lopi, Jøtul, Hearthstone, Blaze King, Pacific Energy, Quadra-Fire and Osburn.
  • Traditional open-style zero-clearance units: Superior (Renaissance), Heatilator, Majestic and Napoleon. These are chosen mainly for the look of an open fire.
  • Masonry alternatives: Isokern (modular pumice kits), Rumford fireplace kits, and masonry heaters such as Tulikivi. A Rumford fireplace is a tall, shallow firebox that radiates more than a standard open fireplace, but it’s still far less efficient than a closed unit.

Open fireplaces are generally about 10% efficient or less. Certified closed units are commonly around 70% to 80%.

Warranties

Many premium brands offer limited lifetime coverage on the firebox. Coverage on parts such as gaskets, glass or controls is often shorter. Read the warranty terms before you buy, and note the conditions, such as the installer you use and the fuel you burn.

Installation matters as much as the brand

A good unit installed badly is a poor unit. Keep these points in mind:

Local rules

Some regions restrict which wood-burning fireplaces can be installed. Washington, parts of California and parts of Colorado have rules like this. Check your local building department before you choose a unit.

Checklist before you buy

  • Decide between a zero-clearance unit, an insert or a masonry option.
  • Confirm the exact model’s EPA certification and tested efficiency.
  • Check the heat output against your room size and insulation, not just the maximum rating.
  • Read the warranty terms.
  • Find an installer who will install that brand and handle the permit.
  • Confirm the unit is allowed where you live.

The complete guide to inserts and conversions

Converting a Fireplace to a Wood Stove: Options, Costs and Steps
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →