Inserts and Conversions

How to Remove or Permanently Close a Wood Burning Fireplace

Compare three ways to deal with an old wood fireplace: seal it, remove the chimney above the roof, or demolish it, plus costs, permits and asbestos checks.

On this page
  1. Quick answer
  2. Before you start
  3. Check for asbestos and lead
  4. Option 1: Seal and close the fireplace
  5. Option 2: Remove the chimney above the roofline
  6. Option 3: Full demolition
  7. Can you remove a fireplace without removing the chimney?
  8. Patching the floor, walls and roof
  9. Costs at a glance
  10. What to put in place of the fireplace
  11. If you might want to use it again
  12. Label it and disclose it
  13. Safety

Quick answer

You have three main options. You can seal the fireplace and leave the chimney in place, remove the chimney above the roofline, or fully demolish the fireplace and chimney. Sealing is the least work and the lowest cost. Full removal is structural work that usually needs a permit and an engineer, and it costs considerably more. Anything on the roof or in the structure is a job for licensed professionals.

Before you start

  • Check whether the chimney serves anything else. A chimney may also vent a furnace, boiler or water heater. Don’t seal or remove an active flue. A technician can confirm this.
  • Get the structure assessed. Masonry fireplaces and chimneys can weigh several tons. Footings and framing may rely on the chimney. Ask a structural engineer before removing any lower sections.
  • Get the right permit. Most jurisdictions require a demolition or building permit for chimney removal or structural changes. Your insurer may also ask about this.
  • Plan for the repairs. Floors, ceilings, walls and the roof will need patching after the work.

Check for asbestos and lead

Fireplaces built before about 1980 may contain asbestos in flue liners, cement or insulation, and lead paint may be present. Get the materials tested before you cut, break or demolish anything. Finding asbestos partway through a job means stopping work until it’s handled, so test first.

Option 1: Seal and close the fireplace

Sealing keeps the chimney but makes the fireplace unusable. A typical seal includes:

  • a cap or seal at the top of the chimney
  • a sealed damper, or a metal plate fixed in place
  • a filled or covered firebox opening

Don’t rely on the damper alone. Dampers leak air, so they aren’t a permanent seal.

Leave a small vent. A sealed flue with no ventilation can trap moisture, which damages masonry and drywall and can encourage mold. A grille in the closed opening and a ventilated cap let air move through. Sealing costs roughly $300 to $1,500, depending on the work.

Option 2: Remove the chimney above the roofline

Removing the chimney above the roof takes out the stack, cowl and flashing, and leaves the fireplace below in place. The roof must then be patched so it’s watertight, and the opening below must be closed properly. Ask the contractor how the flue and firebox will be sealed as part of the job.

This is roof work, so use fall protection or hire a roofer. Removing the stack above the roofline typically costs roughly $1,000 to $4,000 or more, including the roof patch.

Option 3: Full demolition

Full demolition removes the firebox, surround, hearth and chimney. It’s the most work and the most expensive option, at roughly $4,000 to $15,000 or more. Cost depends on the height, access and any structural work.

This is a general outline, not a DIY plan. A contractor will usually follow the engineer’s sequence and these broad steps:

  1. Permit and assessment. Get the permit, the engineer’s sign-off and the asbestos test before anything comes out.
  2. Protect the room. Lay heavy drop cloths over the floor. Hang plastic barriers around the work area, and use a fan in a window to pull dust outside. Wear eye protection, gloves, and a dust mask or respirator rated for fine dust.
  3. Clear the firebox. Remove the ash and loose debris. Then remove any stove, insert or metal parts, including trim, blower wiring and vent pipe.
  4. Take down the surround. Remove the mantel and facing carefully to limit damage to the drywall. Break out tile, stone or brick with a hammer, chisel or rotary hammer.
  5. Take down the masonry. Follow the engineer’s plan. Where it calls for it, work from the top down so the load and debris stay under control.
  6. Patch the openings. Close the roof, ceiling and walls, and restore the floor or hearth.

Can you remove a fireplace without removing the chimney?

In many cases, yes. You can close the flue, remove the firebox and hearth, and leave the chimney stack in place. The chimney is still part of the roof, though, so it has to stay sound. Unused chimneys still need checks. Crowns, flashing and caps can fail and leak, so have them inspected after the work.

Patching the floor, walls and roof

Patching the damage is often the largest added cost. Expect to replace or repair:

  • drywall or plaster around the opening and in the ceiling
  • the subfloor, flooring or tile where the raised hearth was
  • shingles, tiles or flashing where the chimney passed through the roof

Costs at a glance

Option Typical cost What’s included
Seal and close About $300 to $1,500 Chimney cap or seal, damper seal, vent
Remove above the roofline About $1,000 to $4,000 or more Stack removal and roof patch
Full demolition About $4,000 to $15,000 or more Fireplace, surround, chimney and patching

These ranges vary by region and by the job. Get written quotes that list the work and the permits.

What to put in place of the fireplace

Once the fireplace is closed or removed, the room needs a new focal point or a finished wall. Some people add a different heating appliance, while others build a flat wall. If you’re considering a replacement, see replacing a wood fireplace with electric. If you’d prefer to keep the heat and change the fuel, converting between gas and wood covers the options.

If you might want to use it again

Closing a fireplace isn’t always permanent. If you want to use it later, have a Level 2 inspection and any repairs done before the first fire. If the fireplace has been sealed for years, have it checked before it’s used again.

Label it and disclose it

Label the closed fireplace clearly and mention it when you sell the home, so no one lights a fire in it by mistake.

Safety

  • Hire an engineer and get a permit for any structural removal.
  • Test for asbestos before you disturb old flues or cement.
  • Use fall protection for any roof work.

The complete guide to inserts and conversions

Converting a Fireplace to a Wood Stove: Options, Costs and Steps
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →