Quick answer
It depends on how the fireplace was built. A masonry wood-burning fireplace that was later fitted with gas logs can usually go back to wood. A factory-built gas fireplace, such as a metal box with a glass front and a metal vent pipe, can’t be converted in place. Its unit and venting have to be replaced with equipment rated for wood.
When it’s easy: masonry with gas logs
If the original firebox is brick, stone or block, with a damper and a tile-lined chimney, the job is much more manageable. A previous owner may have added gas logs to a wood fireplace. Going back to wood then involves:
- a licensed gas fitter to cap the gas line
- removing the gas logs and burner
- restoring or replacing the damper
- a chimney inspection and sweep
- a stainless steel liner if the existing flue isn’t suitable
The inspection is required when the fuel type changes under NFPA 211, and it often finds cracked flue tiles, a missing cap, a bad crown, or a damper that was removed or clamped open. Those repairs are part of the cost.
When it isn’t feasible: factory-built gas units
A factory-built gas fireplace, a sealed direct-vent unit, or a ventless unit can’t safely burn wood. Its firebox doesn’t have the thermal mass and high-temperature construction needed for a wood fire, and its gas vent isn’t rated for wood smoke. Burning wood in one violates the safety standards and creates a serious fire and carbon monoxide risk.
The route is to remove the whole unit and its venting, then install a wood-rated fireplace or stove with a Class A chimney. The work is much larger than a masonry conversion.
How to tell which you have
- Masonry. The firebox is brick, stone or block. You’ll see a damper and a tile-lined chimney, and the box is heavy.
- Factory-built. The firebox is a metal box with a glass front, and the vent is a metal pipe. Some factory units have a brick-look facade, so don’t rely on appearance alone.
If you’re not sure, have a certified chimney sweep or hearth professional look at it before you make any changes.
Why you can’t just pull out the gas logs
A common question is whether you can pull out the gas logs and burn wood on the grate. In a masonry fireplace, the logs can come out, but only after the gas line has been capped by a licensed fitter. The burner is part of the gas system, and the gas line can’t be left live or buried under rocks. The chimney also has to be inspected first, since it may have been built or altered for gas.
A factory unit is different. It can’t burn wood at all, however the logs are arranged.
What the conversion involves
For a masonry fireplace, the steps are covered in converting between gas and wood. In short: inspect the chimney, cap the gas line, remove the gas equipment, restore the damper, sweep and line the chimney if needed, and get a permit and final inspection.
For a factory-built unit, see converting a fireplace to a wood stove for the wood-rated options, and how hard it is to add a gas fireplace to an existing home for the reverse direction.
What it costs
These are typical ranges, and they vary by region and by the work involved:
- Masonry with gas logs, to wood: about $200 to $1,000, covering the gas capping, the sweep and the inspection. A liner is extra.
- Factory-built gas unit, to wood: about $4,000 to $15,000 or more, depending on the removal, the new chimney and the appliance.
Alternatives
If the fireplace can’t take wood, or the work is more than you want, consider:
- A wood insert or pellet insert in a masonry fireplace, if the firebox and chimney are sound. See fireplace inserts: types and models.
- A realistic gas log set in a masonry fireplace, if you want the look of a wood fire without the wood.
- Removing the gas unit and closing the opening. See how to get rid of a gas fireplace.