Quick answer
Choose a fireplace insert if you have a sound fireplace and chimney that you want to keep. Choose a zero-clearance (ZC) fireplace if you’re building new, have no fireplace, or the existing one is damaged beyond repair or being replaced.
What a fireplace insert is
An insert is a closed heating appliance that slides into an existing fireplace opening, usually a masonry one. It vents through a liner in the existing chimney. A decorative metal surround covers the gap between the unit and the opening. Wood inserts are tested to UL 1482.
What a zero-clearance fireplace is
A zero-clearance fireplace is a factory-built, or prefab, metal firebox. It’s designed to be framed into a wall close to combustible materials, and it uses its own listed chimney system. You don’t need an existing fireplace to install one.
“Zero clearance” doesn’t mean the unit can touch wood everywhere. It still needs the clearances and standoffs set out in its manual. Wood ZC fireplaces are tested to UL 127.
How to tell which one you have
Start with the fireplace you already have:
- Masonry (brick, stone or block). A masonry firebox and chimney usually means an insert is the option to consider.
- Factory-built (metal). Look inside the firebox for a manufacturer’s label or data plate. The label tells you the make and listing, which controls what can go in.
If you still can’t tell, ask a chimney sweep or a dealer to look at it before you buy anything.
Keep in mind that an insert can only go into a zero-clearance fireplace if the insert is listed for that unit and the manufacturer allows it. Most combinations aren’t permitted. Mixing generic chimney pipe with a ZC unit also voids its listing.
What is the point of a fireplace insert?
An insert turns an open, inefficient fireplace into a closed appliance that burns fuel more completely and puts more of the heat into the room. An open masonry fireplace sends much of its heat up the chimney. Figures vary by model and test, but open masonry fireplaces are often cited at around 10% efficiency or less, while EPA-certified inserts and ZC units commonly reach roughly 70% to 80%.
Key differences
| Insert | Zero-clearance fireplace | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it goes | Into an existing fireplace opening | Framed into a new or remodeled wall |
| Venting | A liner in the existing chimney | The manufacturer’s listed chimney system |
| Finish | Surround covers gaps around the opening | Flush finish, with stone, tile or drywall to the edge |
| Installation | Simpler if the chimney is sound; liner adds cost | Needs a framed chase, a roof or wall penetration, and a hearth extension |
| Works best when | You have a sound fireplace and chimney | You have no fireplace, or the existing one can’t be saved |
On the appearance side, a ZC fireplace lets you run stone, tile or drywall right up to the firebox edge. An insert is framed by a surround panel.
Efficiency and lifespan
EPA-certified ZC wood units and inserts reach roughly 70% to 80% efficiency. Open ZC fireplaces without that certification perform much lower. A high-efficiency ZC unit isn’t necessarily weaker than an insert. Rules differ, though. Some ZC wood units are certified as wood heaters, while fireplaces fall under EPA’s voluntary program and state rules, so check which standard applies to the unit you’re considering.
Many older ZC fireplaces wear out after roughly 20 to 30 years. Warped firebox panels and failed chimney sections are the usual signs.
Cost
Costs vary by region and by project. As a rough guide:
- Insert: about $3,500 to $7,000 installed, including the liner.
- Zero-clearance wood fireplace: about $5,000 to $15,000 or more, including the chimney, framing and finish.
A new chimney liner can be a large part of an insert project, so get the liner priced separately. Whether you need a chimney liner for a fireplace insert explains when one is required.
Which one should you choose?
- Choose an insert if the existing firebox and chimney are sound, you want to keep the fireplace, and you want to avoid building a new chase.
- Choose a zero-clearance fireplace if you’re building or remodeling a room with no fireplace, or if the existing one is damaged, unsafe, or being replaced anyway.
- Measure before you buy an insert. The unit has to fit the opening, the hearth and the surround. How to measure your fireplace for an insert walks through the numbers. For the range of insert styles, see fireplace inserts: types and models.
Safety and listing rules
- Follow the manual’s clearances. “Zero clearance” still has required clearances.
- Never modify ZC panels, air channels or chimney components. Modifications void the listing.
- Replace damaged refractory panels with the manufacturer’s parts before you burn.
- Don’t mix chimney parts from different manufacturers.