Quick answer
An insert that isn’t warming the room is usually held back by one of a few things: wet wood, a blower that’s off or not working, air settings closed too early, weak draft, air leaks, or a room that’s too large or too closed off for the unit. Start with the most common cause, which is what you’re burning, and work through the list.
Start with the wood
Wet wood is the most common reason an insert underperforms. Damp wood burns cool and smoky, and much of its energy goes into driving off water instead of heating the room. Check your wood with a moisture meter on a freshly split face. Aim for about 20% moisture or less.
Seasoning takes time. Softwood often needs roughly 6 to 12 months to dry, and dense hardwood often needs 1 to 2 years. The exact time depends on your climate and how the wood is stacked. Kiln-dried wood can take on moisture again if it’s left uncovered outdoors, so keep it under cover and off the ground.
Check the blower
Most flush inserts depend on a blower to push heat out into the room. Without it, much of the heat stays in the unit and the surround, and the room warms slowly. Check that:
- The blower is switched on, and its speed control is set to a usable level.
- The air intake and outlet aren’t blocked by furniture, curtains or dust.
- The fan is clean. Dust on the blades cuts airflow. Clean it at least once a year, or as the manual advises.
- The blower works at all. A failed fan or a wiring fault needs a technician.
Adjust the air control and the fire
A closed air control, set too early, smothers the fire. You get a smoldering fire with low heat, heavy smoke and sooty glass. Once the wood has caught, open the air control so the fire burns bright and active. Only then turn it down for a longer burn.
Don’t try to fix a weak fire by loading more wood. An overloaded firebox smolders, and smoldering leaves creosote in the flue. A small, hot fire heats better than a large, smothered one. If the firebox is cold, build a bed of hot coals before you add larger splits.
Look for leaks and missing parts
Several parts keep heat in the firebox and out of the chimney. Check them against the manual:
- Baffle and burn tubes. A missing or misplaced baffle or set of burn tubes lowers efficiency and sends heat up the chimney.
- Block-off plate. Many inserts need a sheet-metal plate sealed around the liner at the damper area. Without it, heat escapes into the chimney and cold air can drop down into the room.
- Door gasket. A worn gasket lets in extra air. To test it, close the door on a dollar bill. If the bill pulls out easily, the seal needs attention.
- Liner insulation. An uninsulated liner loses heat, which weakens the draft. Some installations need insulation around the liner for the draft and for clearances.
Check the draft and liner
Poor draft means the fire doesn’t get enough air and smoke doesn’t leave cleanly. Common causes include an uninsulated liner, an exterior chimney, a short chimney, and negative pressure from exhaust fans that pull air down the flue. If the fire struggles to draw, or smoke comes into the room, call a chimney professional before you change settings. They can check the liner, the chimney height and the connections. If you’re unsure whether your chimney needs a new liner, see whether you need a chimney liner for a fireplace insert.
Consider the room and layout
An insert mainly heats the room it sits in, and the rooms with a clear path for warm air to travel. Check these points:
- Size. An undersized insert won’t heat a large space, however well it’s running. The manual or listing gives the space the unit is designed for.
- Layout. Closed doors, a separate room, or a long open plan can keep heat from reaching the rest of the house. Leaving doors open or using a ceiling fan on low can help move warm air around.
- Whole-house heat loss. Air leaks and poor insulation elsewhere in the house can overwhelm any heater, including a good insert.
If you’re not sure the unit is the right size, measuring the fireplace for an insert and comparing the numbers with the manual is a good first step. For a broader look at choices and types, see fireplace inserts: types and models.
Expect a slow warm-up
A masonry surround absorbs heat at first. After a cold start, the room can feel cool for a while even when the fire is burning well. This is normal, and it’s a different problem from an insert that never warms the room.
Safety checks
- Never overfire. If the insert or its connector glows red, close the air control and follow the manual’s guidance.
- Check for creosote. Black, shiny buildup in the flue means the chimney needs sweeping before the next fire.
- Keep alarms working. Install a carbon monoxide alarm and smoke alarms, and check that the CO alarm is near the appliance.
When to call a professional
Call a certified chimney sweep or an installer if:
- the fire won’t draw, or smoke comes back into the room
- you see cracked panels, a damaged liner or a failed blower
- you find heavy creosote
- the problem continues after you’ve checked the wood, the settings and the parts