No single type of fireplace adds the most value everywhere. Value depends on your region, your climate, the price point of the home and what buyers in your area expect. In general, a working, inspected fireplace in good condition is worth more to a buyer than a nonworking one or one with an unclear history. Gas units and inserts are popular for convenience. Electric units add ambience, but they add little resale value.
Why there’s no reliable number
You’ll see figures online, such as “adds $12,000” or “up to 12% more.” Those numbers are old or weakly sourced, so treat them as uncertain. Buyer surveys regularly list fireplaces among desirable features, but the rankings change from year to year and from survey to survey.
Don’t count on getting the full cost of a new fireplace back at sale. Most of the time, that doesn’t happen.
How the types compare
- Wood-burning masonry: Carries the most character appeal, especially in cold or rural markets. Building a new masonry fireplace is expensive, and costs vary widely by region.
- Gas fireplaces and inserts: Popular with buyers for convenience. Installed costs commonly run from about $3,000 to $7,000 or more, depending on the unit and the work involved.
- Wood inserts in an existing fireplace: Open masonry fireplaces are often only around 10 percent efficient or less. An EPA-certified insert can raise efficiency substantially, into the range of roughly 65 to 80 percent, depending on the model.
- Electric fireplaces: The cheapest to buy, from about $200 to $3,000 or more. They add ambience, but they add little resale value.
- Outdoor fireplaces: Valued mainly in warm climates. Their effect on value varies by market.
Cheapest boost: cosmetic updates
For most homeowners, the least expensive way to improve a tired fireplace is a cosmetic update. Paint, a new mantel and new doors cost far less than a new unit. For steps, see how to make your fireplace look more modern and how to update a brass fireplace.
Condition and inspection matter more than type
A nonworking fireplace or a failed chimney inspection can lower the sale price, or it can become a point of negotiation. NFPA 211 calls for a Level 2 chimney inspection when a property is sold. Have the chimney inspected before you list the home, and disclose any known defects.
Local rules can change the answer
Some areas restrict new wood-burning devices. Some Bay Area jurisdictions don’t allow them in new construction, and Montreal allows only certified devices. Vent-free gas units are restricted in some places, which can make buyers wary. Check the current rules where you live, because they change.
Common misconceptions
- Adding a fireplace returns its full cost at sale. It usually doesn’t.
- An electric fireplace adds as much value as gas or wood. It usually doesn’t.
- All buyers prefer wood-burning. Many prefer gas for convenience.
- Any existing fireplace is an asset. Its condition decides how much it’s worth.
For more ideas across the whole fireplace, see fireplace makeover ideas.